I remember sitting at my desk, hemming and hawing over my syllabus.  I wasn’t worried about the course schedule or readings – I’d worked those out weeks ago.  The bio and details, the grading policies: fine.  No, the thing that was bothering me was the tech policy.

It used to be plainly obvious that screens in the classroom would not be allowed.  I heard teachers and tenured professors muttering amongst themselves of students texting each other in class, playing video games during lectures – all the moralizing justifications you hear for such a policy.  But honestly, if my class was so dull that it bored a student, that would be my fault, not theirs. I was teaching a university course.

Privately, I always loved the fact that screens weren’t permitted in most places.  My ADHD makes me extremely distractible, and the bright lights and moving images of a laptop, even one simply taking notes on a bright white Word document or hovering over a linked entry on Perseus, can catch and hold my attention when I’d rather hear what the professor has to say.

But now, I understood that for some people, laptops are an accessibility tool.  How could I balance my own need as a teacher with the potential needs of my students? 

Here are a few things I tried that didn’t work.

  • Having a no-screens policy anyway.

This was a great success as far as my comfort was concerned, but almost immediately led to problems with students who had access needs.  I hadn’t thought about it that first time, and I felt horrible for having overlooked something so obvious.

  • Having no tech policy at all.

This was a great success as far as my students were concerned, but honestly, I felt like this was my worst experience teaching.  I constantly had to wrench my thoughts back from wherever they would drift as I passed a student having a private chat via Facebook or shopping for handbags while I lectured.  It was miserable.

  • Having a policy that stated that students could use laptops only, and only if they brought in a medical exemption.

At first, I was truly pleased with this solution, but it soon became clear that it wasn’t working as intended.  I had never realized how hard it was for many students to navigate the university’s disability system, and just how many students didn’t think of their need as deserving of such a thing in any case.  I spent some time reflecting on my own experience; I had never once thought to pursue a formal diagnosis of my ADHD and look for accommodations as an undergraduate.  Even as a graduate student, the most I did was informally request that my supervisors understand my difficulties (which, by and large, they did not).

Finally, having agonized over this for years, through multiple classes and many guilt-ridden Twitter binges, I have come to the conclusion that the best you can achieve, as a teacher, is compromise with open understanding.

Talk to your students.  Be open that this is something you experience, too.  The best results I have ever gotten were from a class where I discussed my technology policy by saying:

I have ADHD.  I get distracted by screens, by repetitive or high-pitched noises, by low-voiced comments and phone buzzes.  These are my limitations, the accommodations that I am asking you, as my students, to make for me.  If you have technology that makes it easier for you to concentrate, to take notes, to do the work you set out to do in my class, you should have access to it, and I’m not going to ask you not to.  Instead, let’s work together to be considerate of each other’s needs.  If you have a screen, try to make sure it’s always focused on the class, and keep it as unobtrusive as possible.  I’ve done my best to make this class accessible, but if I can make things easier for you in any way, all you need to do is shoot me an email or come talk to me.

I’m here with you, I told them.  I’m human too – I understand.

It’s easy, as a neurodivergent teacher, to lose yourself in the need to accommodate all your students without making them work for it.  But you aren’t doing your best when your own needs aren’t met.  And it’s tempting, too, to give in to the rationalizations that allow your needs to be met without giving too much thought to others.  But your students learn less, and you do them a personal disservice, when you come in with such an antagonistic attitude. 

The only way I’ve found to move forward with everyone’s needs met is transparency and mutual accommodation.  You don’t have to say why you need things, but even just knowing that you have needs, and that students can help you, will go a long way towards making them feel safe in accepting what they need, too.

Julie Levy

Categories: ADHDTeaching

Cora Beth

Cora Beth Fraser is the founder and director of Asterion. You can find her full profile on the 'About' page.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.